UpNest vs. Redfin: Pros, Cons, and Alternatives

Leandra Beabout's Photo
By Leandra Beabout Updated October 13, 2023
+ 1 more

SHARE

What is UpNest?

UpNest is an online real estate company that matches home buyers and sellers with agents at top local brokerages.

Like all agent matching services, UpNest is free and comes with no obligation to use one of its agents. What makes UpNest different is how it offers potential savings on realtor fees. Instead of pre-negotiating a discounted commission, the company aims to drive down fees by having agents compete for your business.

Some UpNest customers save more money than others — and some don't get a discounted rate. 

If your main priority is connecting with a shortlist of quality local agents, UpNest is a good choice. But if your top priority is saving money, you might be better off with Redfin or another low commission real estate brokerage. UpNest doesn't guarantee a discount.

» READ: Our full UpNest review

What is Redfin?

Redfin is one of the biggest discount real estate brokerages in the country. It operates in more than 100 US markets. 

Redfin employs its own agents, who charge a 1.5% listing fee — about half of the average real estate commission rate that traditional agents charge. But this reduced fee come at a cost. Redfin agents handle a high volume of customers compared to most agents. 

If your biggest priority is saving money, this tech-centric brokerage is a solid choice. But make sure you research individual agents' ratings and reviews, because sometimes Redfin agents are stretched too thin to offer hands-on support. 

» READ: Our full Redfin review

Editor's take: Real Estate Witch is the better choice

If you want a quality agent who can also save you money, check out Real Estate Witch.

Like UpNest, Real Estate Witch is an agent matching service that lets you choose from a pool of top-producing agents from major brokerages. But instead of asking agents to compete for your business, we have already negotiated a low 1.5% listing fee — the same rate as Redfin. 

There’s no harm in shopping around. You can try UpNest, interview a Redfin agent, and check out agents through Real Estate Witch. But we recommend our platform for the best of both worlds: discounted rates (like Redfin) and multiple quality agents to choose from (like UpNest).

💰 Find top agents, sell for half the typical rate

Don't overpay on realtor fees. We negotiate 1.5% listing fees with top brokers like RE/MAX and Keller Williams. Let us know about your selling situation, and we'll send hand-picked agent recommendations straight to your inbox.

View Agents

UpNest vs. Redfin: Detailed breakdown

Redfin offers cost savings, UpNest doesn't

UpNest doesn't guarantee savings. The idea is for agents to compete for your business by offering discounted rates, but results vary. On average, sellers pay a 2.2% agent commission with UpNest — just under the standard 2.5–3%.

Buying with UpNest gets you a $150 Amazon gift card. Some buyers also save on agent fees, but that's up to the agent to offer.

Redfin does guarantee cost savings. Redfin agents charge a 1.5% fee to sellers or a 1% listing fee to customers who buy and sell with Redfin.

Ultimately, you'll likely save more money with Redfin than UpNest.

MORE: Here's how to get a home buyer rebate

UpNest has a larger agent network

UpNest has more agent selection than Redfin. That's because UpNest doesn't employ real estate agents. Instead, it taps into a nationwide network of agents from traditional real estate brokerages. Like Clever and other agent matching services, it offers multiple matches so you can choose the best fit.

Redfin also operates across the country, but it employs salaried agents. Currently, Redfin has about 2,400 agents across several large metropolitan markets. The number of agents available depends on your location. If you're in Los Angeles, you may get to choose between multiple agents. But in some real estate markets, Redfin doesn't have any agents.

We always recommend interviewing several agents to find the best one for your needs.

UpNest has higher customer satisfaction

UpNestRedfin
4.6/5 (6,342 reviews)3.1/5 (580 reviews)
Show more

Based on aggregate ratings from Google, Facebook, ShopperApp, Consumer Affairs, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau

Customer reviews can give valuable insight into the real estate companies you're considering. In a direct comparison, UpNest's 4.6/5 rating beats Redfin's 3.1/5. But that’s not the whole story.

Most UpNest customers reported a great experience with their agents. Positive reviews praise agents’ professionalism, good communication, and solid industry knowledge. 

Several complaints on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) say that UpNest failed to deliver the promised $150 Amazon gift card to buyers. Some customers also reported that their agents flaked out, which might be a problem because those agents don’t work for UpNest.

Redfin has fewer third-party reviews because it collects reviews directly on its site. Unsurprisingly, the ratings on Redfin’s website are higher than the ratings on Google and Yelp. 

Redfin seems to have more happy than unhappy customers, but reviews are more split with Redfin than UpNest. Redfin has many 5-star and 1-star reviews.

Positive reviews praise insightful, communicative agents. Negative Google reviews mention that agents don’t provide much support after listing the house. Negative Yelp reviews also describe unresponsive, unmotivated agents.

Best alternatives to using UpNest or Redfin

Company
Our Rating
Listing Fee
Availability
5.0
4,037 reviews
1.5%
Min. $3,000
Nationwide
Find Agents
On realestatewitch.com
Good for finding high-quality agents
5.0
6,975 reviews
2%
Min. $3,000
Nationwide
Best for homes over $500k
4.9
277 reviews
1%
Min. $5,000
Multi-state
Best overall

Clever Real Estate

Find Agents
On realestatewitch.com
5.0
4,037 reviews

Listing Fee

1.5%

Our take

Overview

Locations

Clever Real Estate delivers the best combination of savings and service of any competitor that we’ve reviewed. Its agents are held to high standards and provide full service and support for just a 1.5% listing fee, saving you thousands when you sell your home. In states where it's permitted, buyers can also get cash back at closing. Clever has more agents (19,000+) in more markets than most other low-commission options, plus the highest customer rating among brands we evaluated. Unlike some of its competitors, Clever also allows you to choose your own agent. It matches you up with multiple agents, and you can choose the one that best fits your needs.

Read the full Clever Real Estate review.

Pros

  • Low 1.5% listing fee for sellers — about half the typical rate
  • Up to $500 cash back for buyers
  • Agents have strong sales records and great customer reviews
  • Compare agent service packages and credentials before making a decision

Cons

  • Fewer agent options in certain rural areas
  • Add-ons like professional home staging may cost extra

Clever Real Estate offers a 1.5% listing fee, half of what realtors traditionally charge. But you’ll still get a top local real estate agent, so you’ll save thousands without sacrificing quality.

How it works: After filling out an online questionnaire, Clever matches you with realtors in your area. You can choose to work with one of the agents, request more agent matches, or walk away with zero obligations.

Why we like it: Clever is the perfect balance of savings and quality: You get all the services and support of a traditional agent, but you pay a fraction of the typical price. By comparing agents, you ensure you’re getting the realtor who's right for you.

Clever is available nationwide.

Find top agents near you.
Good for finding high-quality agents

Ideal Agent

Learn More
On realestatewitch.com
5.0
6,975 reviews

Listing Fee

2%

Our take

Overview

Locations

Ideal Agent can connect you with a full-service realtor at a discounted listing fee of 2%. The company has high standards for the agents it recommends, claiming to work with only the top 1% based on sales volume in each agent's market. While the savings aren't as significant as some low commission alternatives, customers are generally happy with the outcome from their home sale. Not that buyers won't qualify for any saving with Ideal Agent, and the company's small network size means your agent selection will be limited.

Read our full Ideal Agent review.

Pros

  • Matched with a vetted, full-service realtor
  • 2% listing fee is slightly below industry average

Cons

  • Don't get to choose who you're matched with
  • Other brands offer better savings

Ideal Agent matches sellers and buyers with traditional agents. The company negotiates 2% listing fees with its realtors and screens them for quality and experience.

A 2% listing fee is decent, but you could save more with the 1.5% that Clever and Redfin offer.

Ideal Agent’s partner realtors are good, but there aren’t very many of them, and they’re mostly located in big cities. There’s no guarantee Ideal Agent will have a realtor in your area, and if they do, you’ll get matched with only one.

Ideal Agent is available nationwide.

Best for homes over $500k

Simple Showing

Learn More
On realestatewitch.com
4.9
277 reviews

Listing Fee

1%

Our take

Overview

Locations

SimpleShowing offers a 1% listing fee, subject to a $5,000 minimum — meaning you need to sell a home worth $500,000 or above to qualify for the full savings. Buyers can also save with SimpleShowing, though the buyer rebate comes with numerous restrictions. Apart from the savings, customers are pleased with their agents' availability and guidance through various aspects of their real estate transactions.

Pros

  • 1% listing fee is among the lowest in the industry
  • Customer reviews are overwhelmingly positive.
  • Buyers get up to 1% cash back on their home purchase

Cons

  • $5,000 minimum fee means you must sell for $500,000+ to get full savings
  • Home buyer rebate decreases after 10th home tour

SimpleShowing offers a 1% listing fee with a minimum of $5,000. If you're selling a home for less than $500,000, you’ll pay more than 1% in listing fees.

Its agents juggle five times as many customers as a typical real estate agent. That isn’t necessarily a deal breaker if you’re selling a desirable home in a hot market. But if you expect your agent to provide more hands-on support, you could be disappointed and end up doing a lot of the work yourself.

SimpleShowing is available in Florida, Georgia, Texas.

Need an Agent?

Connect with top-rated agents near you and save thousands
Not feeling a connection with your partner agent? No problem—you can request a switch or go in another direction.