Published
-
Written by
-
Edited by Josiah Wilmoth
Written by Andrew Whytock
Edited by Josiah Wilmoth
Top We Buy Houses companies in Wisconsin | Should I sell to a We Buy Houses company? | How much do they pay? | Alternatives | FAQs
We Buy Houses in Wisconsin companies buy properties making fast, all-cash offers — then make repairs and flip them for a profit. Because they offer closings in as little as a week, these companies are worth considering if you absolutely need to sell fast.
However, selling your home to a We Buy Houses company typically means leaving a lot of money on the table. Most Wisconsin home sellers will find more value through a traditional home sale.
Before you sign a contract with a We Buy Houses in Wisconsin company, we strongly recommend getting multiple offers. This lets you compare your options, so you can be confident you’re getting a fair price for your house.
If you want to sell your house fast for cash in Wisconsin, we can help you compare your options easily. Our free service matches sellers with vetted cash buyers, saving them time and ensuring a competitive selling price. Request as many offers as you’d like, choose the best one, or walk away any time. Get cash offers from top Wisconsin buyers today!
Quick view: Top 6 Wisconsin We Buy Houses for Cash companies
| 💰 Cash buyer | 💸 Time to offer | 🗓 Time to close |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Clever Offers | Varies | Varies |
| 2. Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer | 24 hours | 7 days |
| 3. Wisconsin House Buyers | 24 hours | 7 days |
| 4. Express Homebuyers | 7 minutes | 7 days |
| 5. We Buy Ugly Houses | After home evaluation | 21 days |
| 6. We Buy Houses | 24–48 hours | 7–14 days |
Top 6 We Buy Houses Companies in Wisconsin
🥇 Clever Offers: Our top pick
Nationwide
- Compare multiple cash offers
- Free comparative market analysis
- Full support from Clever team
Clever Offers is a free service that matches sellers with offers from reputable local and national cash buyers. Sellers can choose the best cash offer, or they can explore alternative home sale options, like seller financing or listing with a local realtor. A Clever concierge will help you decide the best route to take.
Clever Offers is available nationwide, but its network of buyers may be limited in some rural areas. Enter your zip code to see if Clever Offers is available in your area.
Clever Offers is a free service that matches sellers with vetted cash buyers in their area. It’s ideal for sellers who want to compare various offers, get the best deal, and sell a home fast.
Alternatively, sellers can explore other home sale options, like seller financing or listing with a local realtor.
Your Clever concierge can also match you with a local realtor for a free comparative market analysis (CMA) of your property. You can use a CMA to negotiate with investors and get the best price for your home.
The Clever team is available for any support you need during the process, including buyer communications, offer rejections, and more.
» MORE: Clever Offers in review
🥈 Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer: Fast and professional
Local
- (414) 435-2888
- Offer in 24 hours
- Close in 7 days
Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer, has been a local, family-owned business since 1999, and it purchases houses in Milwaukee and the surrounding suburbs. It schedules closing around sellers’ needs and can close in less than a week. It is highly rated, and reviewers said their rep was professional, offered fair prices, and made their selling experience smooth and easy.
Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer purchases homes throughout Milwaukee.
Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer is a local, family-owned business that purchases houses in Milwaukee and the surrounding suburbs. Established in 1999, this We Buy Houses in Milwaukee company tops our list because of its longtime experience in the local market and its overwhelmingly positive customer reviews.
Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer will make a cash offer within 24 hours and can close in fewer than 14 days, or later depending on your needs. The team will make an offer first, then visit your house to discuss the process if you accept. This is somewhat unusual, as most cash buyers make an offer only after physically inspecting your house.
The company has all five-star reviews on Google. Former sellers who worked with Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer say their rep was professional, offered fair prices, and made their selling experience smooth and easy. Typical comments include:
- The offer was “extremely fair.”
- The process was efficient, straightforward, and seamless.
- The team was very knowledgeable and easy to work with.
- Closing took 30 minutes and the seller walked out with the check. “Buying a big screen TV was more hassle than this.”
We couldn’t find any negative reviews of Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer, suggesting it offers consistent service.
» MORE: We Buy Houses in Brookfield, WI | Top Companies
🥉 Wisconsin House Buyers: Trusted family-owned business
Statewide
- (608) 721-5994
- Offer in 24 hours
- Close in 7 days
Wisconsin House Buyers is a local, family-owned business that buys homes throughout Madison and Dane County. It can make a final cash offer after a property walkthrough and close in as few as 2 days after accepting the offer. It also provides a $5,000 earnest money deposit guarantee. Reviewers said that its reps are very helpful, transparent, and handle remote transactions well.
Wisconsin House Buyers purchases houses throughout Dane County, primarily in Madison and the surrounding areas.
Wisconsin House Buyers is a family-owned real estate investment firm that buys homes throughout the Dane County area, mainly in Madison and the surrounding communities. It can make a final cash offer after one or two property walkthroughs with its contractors and can close in as quickly as a couple of days, or on your schedule.
Founded in 2016, Wisconsin Home Buyers ranks third on our list because of its positive customer reviews and the focused, local expertise of its home buying team. The company also provides a $5,000 earnest money guarantee, an unusual perk from a cash buyer.
The company has all five-star reviews on Google, with former sellers noting that its team was very honest and hardworking and provided an exceptional experience. Reviewers note:
- The whole process was quick and easy.
- Communication was clear and there were no surprises or hidden fees.
- The team was very prompt, professional, hardworking, and accommodating.
- Wisconsin Home Buyers made an extremely fair offer after just one visit. “We had to do nothing but sign the paperwork.”
Wisconsin House Buyers says it has a 100% closing rate and offers additional services such as help moving and finding a new house.
4. Express Homebuyers: Speed and convenience
Nationwide
- (877) 804-5252
- Offer in 7 minutes
- Close in 7 days
Express Homebuyers has been a nationwide cash buyer since 2003. It makes an all-cash offer after visiting a property and can close in as soon as seven days. Its reviews are largely positive, with previous sellers praising the quick and straightforward transactions it provides. There are a number of negative reviews, however, stating cases of predatory marketing, unresponsiveness, and excessively low offers.
Express Homebuyers purchases homes across Dane and Milwaukee counties.
Express Homebuyers is a nationwide cash buyer that can purchase homes in Milwaukee. The company makes an all-cash offer after visiting a property and can close in as soon as seven days.
Express Homebuyers makes our list because it’s an established brand — the company has purchased over 4,000 homes nationwide since 2003 — with mostly very positive customer reviews. Former sellers generally find that the business delivers fair offers and fast service.
In our review of the nationwide Express Homebuyers brand, we found that sellers often reported the following:
- The team was friendly, polite, and professional.
- The process was “smooth sailing” and the company was very flexible on closing dates.
- “The Express Homebuyers team came to our house and made a fair offer that same day… a truly hassle-free experience.”
Express Homebuyers has also drawn complaints from homeowners who say that the company wasted their time by making an extremely low offer on their home and then continuing to pester them after they turned it down.
Some cash buyer companies may spam you with offers on your home that seem unreasonably low. Remember that you should never sign anything under pressure or accept an unfair offer.
5. We Buy Ugly Houses Wisconsin: Well-known national brand
Nationwide
- (866) 200-6475
- Offer after home evaluation
- Close in 21 days
We Buy Ugly Houses is a network of cash buyer franchises that has been purchasing homes throughout the U.S. since 1996. It can make a final cash offer after completing a property walkthrough and close in as few as 3 weeks.
We Buy Ugly Houses purchases homes across Wisconsin, including Milwaukee, Madison, and Greenbay.
We Buy Ugly Houses, also known as HomeVestors, is a network of cash buyer franchises that has been purchasing homes throughout the U.S. since 1996. It can buy homes across Wisconsin, including Duluth-Superior, Green Bay, La Crosse-Eau Claire, Madison, and Milwaukee.
We Buy Ugly Houses earns a place on our list because of its established reputation and quick service. The company can make a final cash offer after conducting a property walkthrough and close as soon as three weeks later.
Customer reviews of the nationwide We Buy Ugly Houses brand are mixed. Sellers looking for a quick and easy transaction are typically satisfied, with many commenting on the professionalism of the service they received. On the other hand, negative reviews complain about poor service and unfairly low offers from certain franchises.
We Buy Ugly Houses has all five-star reviews on Google for its Duluth and Green Bay franchises, with one reviewer in Duluth saying the rep was very helpful and professional. One negative Yelp review criticizes the brand’s customer service in Milwaukee, but the comment was posted in 2018.
6. We Buy Houses Wisconsin: Vetted investor network
Nationwide
- (877) 932-8946
- Offer in 24-48 hours
- Close in 7-14 days
We Buy Houses is a network of cash buyers that have been buying homes all over the U.S. since 1997. It can make an offer anywhere from 24–48 hours and can close as quickly as seven days. Sellers who left reviews said they were pleased with the fast and easy transactions that the company provided.
We Buy Houses purchases properties across Wisconsin.
We Buy Houses is a network of cash buyers that has been buying homes throughout the U.S. since 1997. It can purchase properties across Wisconsin, making an offer in 24–48 hours and closing as quickly as 7 days later.
We included We Buy Houses on our list because of its positive reviews and vetted buyer network. The company sells exclusive licenses to use its marketing program to professional real estate investors that already have established businesses. This tends to make We Buy Houses investors more credible than the average cash buyer.
In our review of the nationwide We Buy Houses brand, we found that satisfied sellers across the country tended to note the following themes:
- A fast and easy closing process
- Clear communication between the investor and the seller
- Overall satisfaction with the end-to-end service offered by We Buy Houses
Negative feedback is rare, which speaks to the brand’s overall service quality.
Not seeing the right company for you? Check out our list of the top companies that buy houses for cash across the country!
Who should sell to a Wisconsin We Buy Houses company?
We Buy Houses for Cash companies are best for people who need to sell their house immediately, even if it means leaving a lot of money on the table.
If you’re facing one of the following situations, selling to a local cash buyer may be your best (or only) option:
- You’re at immediate risk of losing your home to foreclosure
- You need to sell your home in a matter of days due to external factors
- A realtor has informed you that your home will need serious repairs in order to be market-ready, and you don’t have the time or money to cover these upgrades
However, most home sellers — even those who need to sell quickly! — will be better off listing their home on the open market. An agent can help you price your home to sell fast and in as-is condition — and you’ll typically fetch a lot more money.
Before you go with a We Buy Houses for Cash in Wisconsin company, take a moment to schedule a free consultation with an experienced real estate agent. A realtor will give you a no-obligation home valuation and marketing plan. Then, you can compare that to what the cash buyer is offering, and make a more informed decision.
Consulting a realtor is the best way to ensure that you keep the most equity in your pocket while still selling on your timeline.
Many realtors have relationships with top local cash buyers (and can help you avoid companies that only make lowball offers). Your agent can help you get cash offers from local companies that have good reputations. They can also help you understand your options to find the best way to sell your home within your timeline for as much money as possible.
How do We Buy Houses for Cash companies work?
We Buy Houses for Cash companies in Wisconsin are typically owned by real estate investors. These investors look for deals, most often by searching for distressed or unwanted properties that tend to be less desirable to ordinary home buyers.
They purchase the homes by making fast, all-cash offers that allow them to buy at a discounted price. Then, they make the necessary repairs and re-sell the properties for a profit.
We Buy Houses for Cash pros and cons for Wisconsin home sellers
| ✅ Pros | ❌ Cons |
|---|---|
| Fast, easy closing. These companies typically make an offer within 24–48 hours and close in as little as one week. | Significantly lower sale price. The biggest drawback is that you won't get what your home is actually worth on the open market. |
| No paperwork. Most reputable We Buy Houses companies will take care of all the paperwork for you. | Little room to negotiate. The offer they give you generally doesn't have much wiggle room. |
| No repairs. They'll buy your property as-is without requiring any repairs — even if your home is in poor condition. | No representation. Unlike in a traditional real estate transaction, you won't have an agent to represent your best interests. |
How much do We Buy Houses companies in Wisconsin pay?
We Buy Houses companies and local real estate investors in Wisconsin generally use the 70% rule: never pay more than 70% of a home’s after-repair value (ARV), minus repair costs. You can get a ballpark idea of your home’s ARV by looking at listing/sale prices of comparable homes in your neighborhood that have been renovated recently.
The median listing price of homes in Wisconsin is $351,250. Assuming a We Buy Houses company believes that your home will be worth that after they’ve made the necessary repairs ($50,000 in this example), they would pay you around $195,875.
(After repair value x 0.70) – Repair costs = Purchase price
($351,250 x 0.70) – $50,000 = $195,875
When is selling to a We Buy Houses company worth it?
Selling to a We Buy Houses company may be worth it if you need to sell your home quickly and don’t have time to make any repairs.
But most sellers will be able to sell their home for a much higher price by listing on the open market.
You need to sell your house fast
| 🗓 Time to sell | 💰 Median listing price | |
|---|---|---|
| Wisconsin | 34 days | $351,250 |
| United States | 50 days | $427,250 |
It takes the average Wisconsin homeowner 34 days to sell a property — which is quite a bit less than the national average of 50 days.
Still, some home sellers may need to sell faster than that — especially if they’re facing a difficult situation like foreclosure or a divorce.
One of the major advantages of a We Buy Houses company is that it can make nearly-instant cash offers, which allow you to get to the closing table in as little as 3 days.
The biggest drawback, however, is that you’ll likely sell your home for a lot less money than you’d make on the open market.
You’re selling a house in poor condition
Another great benefit of a cash buyer like We Buy Houses in Wisconsin is that it will purchase homes in as-is condition. If your home is in need of extensive repairs or is structurally unsound, it may be easier to sell to a We Buy Houses company instead of finding a buyer on the open market.
That said, we recommend talking to an experienced real estate agent before accepting an offer from a We Buy Houses Wisconsin company. In today’s market, there are buyers who are willing to purchase fixer-uppers, and you’ll almost always get more money for your home by selling on the open market.
If you’d like to get an agent’s professional opinion, our partners at Clever can connect you to a top local realtor. You’ll get a free expert home valuation to make sure you’re getting a fair price.
Better alternatives for Wisconsin home sellers
There are two main types of alternatives to selling to a We Buy Houses company in Wisconsin: selling to an iBuyer or listing with a traditional agent.
If you’re selling a newer home that doesn’t need extensive repairs, we recommend getting an offer from an iBuyer.
Listing with a real estate agent is the best way to sell your home for its full value — and an agent can help you compare cash offers to what your home may get on the open market.
Sell to an iBuyer
Like We Buy Houses companies, iBuyers make all-cash offers on homes. They offer the same fast closing timelines, but they typically pay much closer to market value.
But there’s a reason iBuyers pay more than traditional We Buy Houses companies. iBuyers have much stricter purchase criteria and are only available in select areas. If your home was built recently and only needs minor repairs, it may be a good candidate for an iBuyer. Otherwise, it probably won’t qualify.
If you need to sell your Wisconsin home quickly and it’s in good shape, we recommend seeing if there are any iBuyers available in your area. Requesting a cash offer only takes a few minutes, and you can walk away with no obligation if the offer is lower than what you think your home is worth.
List with a Wisconsin realtor who specializes in quick sales
Every seller should start their selling journey with an expert home valuation from a local real estate agent — even if you ultimately decide to sell to accept a cash offer from a We Buy Houses company or iBuyer.
Getting a home valuation is free, no-risk, and allows you to ensure that you’re making the right decision.
In the current Wisconsin real estate market, many top agents can still sell your home quickly. They can even target individual cash buyers and investors, allowing you to sell your home as-is while still getting top dollar for your home.
FAQs about We Buy Houses companies in Wisconsin
Are We Buy Houses companies in Wisconsin legit?
Most We Buy Houses in Wisconsin companies are legitimate and honest, but not all. Some will take advantage of desperate sellers — which is why it’s important to read reviews to find the good ones. For instance, former sellers said that Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer’s reps made fair offers and were very helpful. Another great alternative is to sell to a larger, more established company like We Buy Ugly Houses in Wisconsin.
How much money will a We Buy Houses company pay in Wisconsin?
We Buy Houses for Cash companies typically pay less than a property's after-repair value — but they also provide fast transactions. For example, Wisconsin House Buyers can close in as few as two days after accepting the offer, perfect for desperate sellers who need to sell quickly. To find out more, check out our guide on We Buy Houses for Cash companies.
How can I sell my property quickly in Wisconsin?
One way to get a fast offer and close quickly on a Wisconsin property is to sell to a local cash buyer. Case in point, Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer can make an offer within 24 hours and close in as few as two days after signing a contract.
However, most sellers will benefit from consulting a low commission real estate agent before accepting a cash offer. An experienced realtor may be able to help you sell your home fast — while keeping more of your hard-earned equity in your pocket.
More We Buy Houses for Cash resources
Want to learn more about how We Buy Houses companies work and what you should watch out for as a home seller? Check out these great resources!
Companies That Buy Houses for Cash [In-Depth Guide]: You might be willing to sell to a We Buy Houses company if you’re in a bind, but is it worth it? Find out how these companies operate.
Are “We Buy Houses” Companies a Ripoff? Cardboard signs at the side of the road don’t seem very professional, so what’s the deal with all of these companies that advertise “We Buy Houses in Wisconsin” on highway billboards? Learn how to tell the difference between a legitimate cash buyer and a scam.
How Much Will an Investor Pay for My House? Investors don’t buy houses because they love them — they buy them to make a profit. Learn more about how an investor would price your home if they were interested in buying it.
More Wisconsin home selling guides
Average Realtor Fees in Wisconsin: Real estate commission fees are typically the largest expense you’ll have when you sell your home. Learn how much you should expect to pay as a Wisconsin homeowner — and get some tips on how to save on realtor fees!
The 3 Best Flat Fee MLS Companies in Wisconsin: If you’re selling your house for sale by owner (FSBO), a flat-fee MLS company can help you get your listing on the MLS — where it will reach the most potential buyers. But not all of these companies offer great overall value. Here’s what you should know as a Wisconsin FSBO seller.
How to Sell a House Without a Realtor in Wisconsin: Some homeowners wonder if it’s really worth it to pay a realtor to sell their home. But before you take the leap into doing it yourself, check out this guide on what being a for sale by owner seller actually looks like in the Badger State.
Leave a Reply