Integrity First Home Buyers: Can You Trust This 'We Buy Houses' Company?

Katy Byrom's Photo
By Katy Byrom Updated April 11, 2024
+ 1 more
's Photo
Edited by Jenny Rollins

SHARE

Integrity First Home Buyers is a veteran-owned company that buys houses for cash in and around York County, Pennsylvania. The company offers homeowners a same-day offer and closes within days.

like most property investors, Integrity First pays below fair market value for homes. But it also negates common home selling costs — including closing costs, commissions, repair costs, or other sale fees. 

The company buys houses as is. So, if your home is in poor condition or has code violations, Integrity First is a potential solution. Integrity First also works well for homeowners who need to sell fast for any reason.

Don't commit to Integrity First Home Buyers right away. Compare all your options, including other Pennsylvania cash buyers and iBuyers. A realtor is a great resource to find you these offers.

If you're looking for a fair cash offer, our team can help. Simply tell us about your property, and we'll send you up to 10 competing offers from serious cash buyers in our network. You can also request a professional estimate of your home value, so you can evaluate offers against your home's potential sale price. Get tailored cash offers from top local buyers — with no added fees or commissions!

Integrity First Home Buyers: What You Need to Know

📍 LocationsHarrisburg, Lancaster, Stewartstown, York, Dover, Gettysburg, Glen Rock, and Hanover
⏱️ Time to offerWithin 7 minutes
⌛ Time to close A few days
🏠 Home typesSingle-family houses, condos, duplexes
✅ What customers loveEase and speed of the sale, selling property as-is
❌ Common complaintsOffers below market value
Show more

Integrity First Home Buyers is a legit 'we buy houses' company. It’s a division of CR Property Group that operates in Adams, Cumberland, Dauphin, Lancaster, Lebanon, and York Counties in Pennsylvania. Integrity First is accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), with an A+ rating. 

York-based real estate investor Eric Brewer owns and manages Integrity First Home Buyers. Brewer has completed more than 3,000 residential real estate deals in Pennsylvania and Maryland since 2006. He launched the company in 2016 to dedicate more resources and services to home buyers.

How Integrity Home Buyers works

Eric buys your house using a three-step process.

  1. Potential customers call the company at (717) 292–8168 or fill out a form on its website. A representative will call you to set up a time to visit your property.
  2. During that meeting, another representative from the company looks at your house and makes a cash offer on the spot.
  3. If you’re satisfied with the offer, you can set up closing in a few days or months, depending on your schedule.

What does Eric Brewer pay for houses?

Eric Brewer at Integrity Home Buyers will likely pay less for your home than what you would get on the open market. 

"We buy houses" companies like Integrity Home Buyers often use the 70% rule when making offers. The rule says investors should pay no more than 70% of the after-repair value (ARV) of the home (minus the estimated repair costs).

For example, a home with an ARV of $300,000 might receive a maximum offer of $210,000 to account for its repair costs. 

But selling to a cash home buyer also means you won’t pay realtor commissions, closing costs, service fees, or other hidden charges. And you can sell your home as is. So, you won't need to clean, fix anything, or schedule showings.

💰 Connect with top agents and save thousands!💰

We negotiate lower commissions with top agents in your area so you can get amazing service and save thousands.

Learn More

Integrity First Home Buyers reviews

Average Rating (0 - 5)Total Reviews
Weighted avg.4.27187
Google4.3124
Facebook4.237
Better Business Bureau4.821
Yelp2.05

Most Integrity First Home Buyers reviewers had good things to say about the company. 

The Facebook reviews are inaccurate. Over half of them appear to be fake comments about investing in cryptocurrency and FOREX. 

But Yelp, Google, and the BBB all have reviews from legitimate consumers. Many found the process easy and quick, without the haggling of a typical real estate sale. 

A few customers sold homes filled with collectibles, furniture, tools, and personal belongings. First Home Buyers buys houses as-is, and these customers were relieved not to have to tackle the nightmare of cleaning out the house.

A common complaint was low offers. That’s typical for ‘We Buy Houses’ PA reviews because cash buyers use the 70% ARV rule.

Who Integrity First Home Buyers works best for

Integrity First Home Buyers might be a good choice for several types of homeowners.

Eric Brewer real estate is a clear winner if you're: 

  • Behind on mortgage payments
  • Facing foreclosure
  • Getting a divorce or separation
  • Inheriting an unwanted property
  • Looking for a way to get cash now
  • Looking for an alternative to an estate sale
  • Moving for a job
  • Retiring or needing to downsize
  • Selling a home with code violations

York County homeowners who need to sell fast

The average time to sell a home in Pennsylvania is 84 days, according to Clever Real Estate. If you can’t wait that long and live in York County or the surrounding areas, Integrity First Home Buyers can make a cash offer immediately and close within days. 

Sellers with homes in poor condition

Eric buys houses as is. So if your house needs expensive repairs, this might be a great option for you.

Integrity First's offer will likely be less than your home's fair market value. But you don’t have to clean up, make repairs, renovate, or stage the home to make it more appealing to buyers.

Integrity First Home Buyers alternatives

Integrity First Home Buyers is a hassle-free way to sell your house fast for cash, but it isn’t your only cash buyer option in Pennsylvania.

‘We buy houses’ for cash companies in Pennsylvania

If you’re looking to sell your house as is, there are other "we buy houses" companies in Pennsylvania. Express Homebuyers, We Buy Ugly Houses, ASAP Cash Home Buyers, and First Choice Home Buyers are a few local companies to consider. 

Our team can present you with multiple competing offers from the top cash buyers in our network. You can also request a professional estimate of your home value, so you can compare offers to what your house is worth on the open market. Get tailored cash offers from top local buyers — with no added fees or commissions!

iBuyers

An iBuyer is another option if you want a quick sale. iBuyers sometimes make higher offers than ‘we buy houses’ companies. But they generally only buy houses in good condition. If your property needs extensive repairs, a cash home buyer might be a better choice. 

Sell on the open market

Selling a house traditionally can often get you a higher sales price, but you might wait weeks or longer to get an offer, and months to close. Still, it might be your best option if you don't need to sell fast and if you want the most money for your house.

FAQs

Are Integrity First Home Buyers' reviews positive? 

Integrity First Home Buyers reviews are mostly positive. Buyers liked the hassle-free process and that they didn't have to clean up the property or pay for repairs.

Who is Eric Brewer in real estate?

Eric Brewer is the president and owner of Integrity First Home Buyers. Eric buys houses in as-is condition, pays cash, and helps homeowners close on the sale in mere days.

Related reading

Express Homebuyers Review: What You NEED to Know. Can you trust this cash home buyer to pay you a fair price for your property? Find out here.  

Is We Buy Houses Legit? We Buy Houses purchases homes in any condition or situation. It's an option to consider if you need to sell ASAP. 

We Buy Ugly Houses: Is It a Rip-off? Learn if this national cash home buyer is legitimate or a scam and if it's the right choice for you.

Authors & Editorial History

Our experts continually research, evaluate, and monitor real estate companies and industry trends. We update our articles when new information becomes available.

Need an Agent?

Connect with top-rated agents near you and save thousands
Not feeling a connection with your partner agent? No problem—you can request a switch or go in another direction.